Canelo vs Munguia: compara la tarjeta de Fernando Barbosa con la oficial

Saúl "Canelo" Álvarez y Jaime Munguia lucharon en una gran batalla para el título supermediano del CMB el pasado 22 de abril de 2024. The fight, which took place in the Jalisco Stadium in Guadalajara, Mexico, was a close-knit and intense match that kept the fans enthralled right up to the very end.

At the end of the evening, the judges declared a majority draw, with two votes in favor of Canelo (114-114) and one against (113-115). However, the judge Fernando Barbosa's tarjet created controversy because it threw the match in favor of Munguia 118–110.

En este artículo, compararemos las tarjetas de Barbosa con la oficial y analizaremos las principales diferencias entre ambas.

Tarjeta Oficial:

Round	Canelo	Munguia
1	10-9	10-9
2	10-9	10-9
3	10-9	10-9
4	10-9	10-9
5	10-9	10-9
6	10-9	10-9
7	10-9	10-9
8	10-9	10-9
9	10-9	10-9
10	10-9	10-9
11	10-9	10-9
12	10-9	10-9

Total: 114-114

Tarjeta de Fernando Barbosa:

Round	Canelo	Munguia
1	10-8	10-8
2	10-8	10-8
3	10-8	10-8
4	10-8	10-8
5	10-8	10-8
6	10-8	10-8
7	10-8	10-8
8	10-8	10-8
9	10-8	10-8
10	10-8	10-8
11	10-8	10-8
12	10-8	10-8

Total: 118-110

Analysis:

As we can see, the only distinction between the two cards is in how the rounds are punched. Barbosa scored every point in favor of Munguia, but the official judges awarded Canelo 10 points and Munguia 2.

This disparity in scoring is due to how each judge interpreted the match. Barbosa seemed to place more value on Munguia's activity, while official judges placed more value on Canelo's accuracy and power.

Nota importante: hay una forma "correcta" de puntar una pelea, y la puntuación de los jueces is subjetiva. However, the Barbosa sticker caused controversy since many fans felt that Munguia did not go far enough.

Conclusion:

The fight between Canelo and Munguia was a close-quarters, intense fight that might have gone either way. There was controversy around Fernando Barbosa's card, but it's vital to remember that judges' decisions are subjective and there is no one "correct" way to score a fight.

In the end, what matters most is that the fans enjoyed the fight and that both fighters gave their best shots.

Canelo vs Munguia: compara la tarjeta de Fernando Barbosa con la oficial